Case Pushed to September Amid Long-Running Legal Battle
The Odisha High Court on Tuesday adjourned until 15 September 2025 the hearing of a long-standing pension entitlement dispute involving retired staff of grant-in-aid schools and colleges. The case, pitting the state government against hundreds of former employees, has been a decade-long saga over the monetary rights of academic personnel in subsidised institutions.
Government Appeals Against Earlier Order
A division bench of Justice Manas Ranjan Pathak and Justice Mruganka Sekhar Sahu was scheduled to hear the state’s writ appeal against a January 12, 2024, single-judge order directing the government to grant pensions and other retirement benefits within three months. That order had also quashed the government’s decision to deny such claims.
During Tuesday’s proceedings, the state sought more time to file its arguments, drawing strong opposition from the counsel for the retirees. The bench, noting the complexity of the matter, agreed to defer the full hearing to mid-September.
Roots of the Dispute Date Back to 2015
The legal battle began when Sharad Chandra Parida, a retired block grant school employee, won a High Court order in 2015 mandating the government to provide pensions and retirement benefits. The state challenged the ruling in the Supreme Court, which upheld the High Court’s decision.
Following this precedent, around 125 pensioners from grant-in-aid institutions—led by petitioner Hemant Kumar Chhotray—sought similar benefits but were denied. This prompted a fresh petition to the High Court, leading to the 2024 ruling now under appeal.
Arguments on Fiscal Burden vs. Employee Rights
Advocate Dr. Purushottam Chuli, representing the retirees, argued that pensions are “deferred remuneration” earned through decades of service in strengthening the education system. The state, however, contends that granting pensions to all grant-in-aid retirees would place an unsustainable burden on the exchequer, sparking an ongoing debate between fiscal prudence and welfare obligations.
Awaiting a Verdict with Far-Reaching Impact
The adjournment has left hundreds of retirees in limbo, uncertain whether their final years will be spent in financial security or hardship. The case has reignited public discussion over the treatment of educators in Odisha’s aided schools and the need for systemic reforms to ensure parity in retirement benefits.
With the next phase of the litigation now set for September, the case is poised to shape the future of pension rights for educators across the state’s academic sector.
Comments are closed.